Philip Simon's solo show was cancelled last year over his views on the Middle East conflict
A venue has accepted that it discriminated against a Jewish comedian when it cancelled his show at last year's Edinburgh Festival Fringe over his views about the Israel-Gaza war.
Philip Simon was due to perform his stand-up show at the Banshee Labyrinth on Niddry Street, but the venue scrapped it at short notice after it carried out "routine" checks on his social media.
It told industry magazine Chortle, external that Simon's views aligned with "groups associated with humanitarian violations", but the comic said he had been cancelled "just for being Jewish".
Simon pursued legal action and on Monday his lawyer David Welsh told a court hearing that the venue had conceded it had acted unlawfully.
He said: "The defender conceded that the defender discriminated against the pursuer, contrary to the provisions of the Equalities Act."
He added: "Following the defence's concession… the whole issue of liability has now been resolved in the pursuer's favour.
"The pursuer has been entirely successful on the question of liability."
Count Binface to perform at Fringe after by-election defeat
How affordable are Edinburgh's festivals?
Amanda Knox comedy show 'sincere' but 'just not very funny'
Simon, from London, had posted a number of remarks on X about the conflict in the Middle East in January 2025.
This included a post where he said Israel had been forced to "capitulate" when it released 1,890 Palestinians – and this amounted to negotiating with "terrorists".
When the Banshee Labyrinth cancelled his solo show, he said: "The reason I was given is that my views concerning the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Palestine… are in significant conflict with our venue's stance against the current Israeli government's policy and actions.
"Anyone who knows me will know I have never expressed support for anything other than freeing the hostages and finding a way to peace.
